|
The Disciplines of Humanity
Science
and Religion, Philosophy and The Arts
Religions
represent what people believe to be true.
There
is no way to objectively and definitively determine which religion or beliefs
actually are true.
5
I
R
E
L
3---
S C I E N C E
---4
G
I
O
N
|
6
-
Science
works on a horizontal level, relating us to this physical
world.
-
Religion
works on a vertical level, relating us to a higher world, to some
other realm.
Transparency
Diagram:
Ways of knowing and ways of expressing; science & technology, arts &
humanities
Religion,
Science and Philosophy - the triangle of knowledge (diagram):
is beliefs about things which can be seen or otherwise perceived with the
senses ("empirical").
Religion
is beliefs about things which can’t be seen, our attempt to understand
aspects of reality beyond the limits of our senses and reason.
Science
starts with (is based in) the outer world, the world of matter
Religion
starts with (is based in) the inner world, the world of the spirit
Relationship
between religion and philosophy (transparency):
-
While
philosophy is rational, religion is non-rational (not irrational).
-
While
philosophy is based on logic, religion relies on intuition
(faith).
-
In
addition, religion is communal and social in nature while philosophy
is, for the most part, the work of individual thinkers.
-
Religion
guides our everyday lives in practical ways often through rules and
regulations. Philosophy often remains merely theoretical. Philosophy becomes
religion in the moment it is lived.
-
Philosophy
may comprise beliefs about reality (metaphysics) but religion lives
according to the ramifications of those beliefs.
Scientist
Freeman Dyson, winner of the year 2000 Templeton Prize for Progress in
Religion, considers:
…science
and religion to be two windows through which we look out at the world. Neither
window by itself gives a complete view. The windows are different but the
world outside is the same. Religion and science can live harmoniously together
in the human soul as long as each respects the other’s autonomy, so long as
neither claims infallibility. Conflicts occur when organized science or
organized religion claims a monopoly on truth…
Science
is very good at telling us what we need to know about the physical world and
universe. But science does not and cannot tell us anything about ethics, morals
and values. That is where religion and philosophy come in:
-
Science
can help us avoid or end an unwanted pregnancy but it takes philosophy and
religion to tell us if we should or not
-
Science
can maintain life through artificial life support but it is philosophy and
religion that tell us if we should or not
-
Science
can clone animals and maybe, one day, humans but it is philosophy and
religion that tell us if we should or not
"Can
we?" belongs to the physical world of science.
"May
we?" belongs to the world of ethics as found in philosophy and
religion.
No
matter how much science can explain about the world we live in, there will still
be room for religion to do what it does best: not explain the "how" of
things but, rather, the "why" and to weigh values.
Science
and religion are the "checks and balances" of each other: too much
science without moral guidance from religion may be a dangerous thing in the
long run; too much religion uninformed by science is superstition.
return
to top
|