| Reflective
      Journaling Rubric | 
  
    | “A”
      quality papers will: see examples | 
        
          Reflect
          a significant degree of new
          and/or deeper understanding and appreciation of the religion in
          question
          Clearly
          demonstrate deep personal impact and transformation from the learning
          process 
          Demonstrate
          excitement about the content learned
          Reflect
          on several specific aspects of the content learned and
          on the overall topic in general
          Relate
          the content of learning to your personal or professional life and/or
          original observations of the world, life, and society in general  | 
  
    | “B”
      quality papers will: | 
        
          Reflect
          a moderate degree of new
          and/or deeper understanding and appreciation of the religion in
          question
          Be
          somewhat superficial (lack depth of thought on aspects discussed)
          Be
          somewhat bland (lack the “excitement” factor)
          Be
          overly focused on a single aspect of the religion in question or be overly generic in
          nature, focusing on nothing specific about the religion in
          question  | 
  
    | In
      addition, both A and B
      papers will: 
        
          Meet
          or exceed the word length requested (header, title and restatement of
          question prompts will not count)
          Limit
          the amount of purely factual information (no more than 20% of the
          paper should deviate from personal reflection – quotes count as
          “fact”)
          Avoid
          excessive criticism and/or rejection of the religion being discussed
          Limit
          discussion based on prior knowledge (reflect on new learning from the
          course content)
          Display
          fairly decent college level writing skills (spelling, grammar,
          diction, punctuation, etc.) | 
  
    | Grade
      reduction for one or more infractions: | -10%  (-1
      grade level) | -20% (-2
      grade levels) | -30% (-3
      grade levels) | -40% (-4
      grade levels) | 
  
    | Too
      short of requested word count | More
      than 10% short of requested word count | More
      than 20% short of requested word count | More
      than 30% short of requested word count | More
      than 40% short of requested word count (½
      credit for ½
      a paper) | 
  
    | Too
      much fact (including quotes) in relation to personal thoughts | More than 20% mere description of facts | More than 40% mere description of facts | More than 60% mere description of facts | 80% mere description of facts (redo) (½
      credit for 100% facts) | 
  
    | Too
      much negativity
      (overly critical or judgmental)  | More than ¼ | More than ½  | More than ¾  | 100% (redo) | 
  
    | Too
      much focus on prior knowledge
      in relation to new learning | More than ¼ relates to prior knowledge | More than ½ 
      relates to prior knowledge | More than ¾ 
      relates to prior knowledge | 100% relates to prior knowledge (redo) | 
  
    | Off topic/irrelevant content | More than 10% (resulting in less than 450
      words on topic) | More than 20% (resulting in less than 400 words on topic)
 | More than 30% (resulting in less than 350 words on topic)
 | More than 40% (resulting in less than 300 words on topic) (½ credit for no more than
      250 words on topic)
 | 
  
    | Too
      many composition problems | Serious and/or numerous composition
      problems that impede comprehension will receive 10% grade reduction | 
  
    | These
      infractions will be cumulative. If you have more than one of the above
      noted infractions, more than one letter grade will be deducted. For
      example: a paper that is 425 words and half fact will receive -10% for
      word length infraction plus another -20% for being too much fact in
      relation to personal reflection. If your quality grade to start is a A,
      the result would be a grade of D for the paper. |