Reflective
Journaling Rubric
|
“A”
quality papers will:
see examples
|
-
Reflect
a significant degree of new
and/or deeper understanding and appreciation of the religion in
question
-
Clearly
demonstrate deep personal impact and transformation from the learning
process
-
Demonstrate
excitement about the content learned
-
Reflect
on several specific aspects of the content learned and
on the overall topic in general
-
Relate
the content of learning to your personal or professional life and/or
original observations of the world, life, and society in general
|
“B”
quality papers will:
|
-
Reflect
a moderate degree of new
and/or deeper understanding and appreciation of the religion in
question
-
Be
somewhat superficial (lack depth of thought on aspects discussed)
-
Be
somewhat bland (lack the “excitement” factor)
-
Be
overly focused on a single aspect of the religion in question or be overly generic in
nature, focusing on nothing specific about the religion in
question
|
In
addition, both A and B
papers will:
-
Meet
or exceed the word length requested (header, title and restatement of
question prompts will not count)
-
Limit
the amount of purely factual information (no more than 20% of the
paper should deviate from personal reflection – quotes count as
“fact”)
-
Avoid
excessive criticism and/or rejection of the religion being discussed
-
Limit
discussion based on prior knowledge (reflect on new learning from the
course content)
-
Display
fairly decent college level writing skills (spelling, grammar,
diction, punctuation, etc.)
|
Grade
reduction for one or more infractions:
|
-10%
(-1
grade level)
|
-20%
(-2
grade levels)
|
-30%
(-3
grade levels)
|
-40%
(-4
grade levels)
|
Too
short of requested word count
|
More
than 10% short of requested word count
|
More
than 20% short of requested word count
|
More
than 30% short of requested word count
|
More
than 40% short of requested word count (½
credit for ½
a paper)
|
Too
much fact (including quotes) in relation to personal thoughts
|
More than 20% mere description of facts
|
More than 40% mere description of facts
|
More than 60% mere description of facts
|
80% mere description of facts (redo) (½
credit for 100% facts)
|
Too
much negativity
(overly critical or judgmental)
|
More than ¼
|
More than ½
|
More than ¾
|
100% (redo)
|
Too
much focus on prior knowledge
in relation to new learning
|
More than ¼ relates to prior knowledge
|
More than ½
relates to prior knowledge
|
More than ¾
relates to prior knowledge
|
100% relates to prior knowledge (redo)
|
Off topic/irrelevant content
|
More than 10% (resulting in less than 450
words on topic)
|
More than 20%
(resulting in less than 400 words on topic)
|
More than 30%
(resulting in less than 350 words on topic)
|
More than 40%
(resulting in less than 300 words on topic) (½ credit for no more than
250 words on topic)
|
Too
many composition problems
|
Serious and/or numerous composition
problems that impede comprehension will receive 10% grade reduction
|
These
infractions will be cumulative. If you have more than one of the above
noted infractions, more than one letter grade will be deducted. For
example: a paper that is 425 words and half fact will receive -10% for
word length infraction plus another -20% for being too much fact in
relation to personal reflection. If your quality grade to start is a A,
the result would be a grade of D for the paper.
|