A COMPARATIVE LOOK AT THE WORLD'S RELIGIONS

by Laura Ellen Shulman

What do we believe about the nature of Ultimate Reality?
(the many names of God - "a rose by any other name...")

Western Traditions:

    The God of the Western, monotheistic religions is understood to be the omnipotent, omniscient, eternal and transcendent creator but also in relationship with humans demanding justice, obedience to God’s will and selfless love toward others.

Indian traditions:

    The eastern religions vary in focus, understanding Ultimate Reality to be either one or many, personal gods and goddesses or a non-personal energy or force creating, maintaining and transforming the cosmos in an ongoing, eternal and repeating process. Often these views will be found side by side in a single tradition differing between popular and philosophical understanding of the same tradition.

There are also many, many personal deities understood as various forms of the one Ultimate Reality. Three primary gods:
  • Brahma, the creator
  • Vishnu, the preserver
  • Shiva, the destroyer (transformer)
  • In practice, Hindus primarily worship some form of Vishnu (e.g. Krishna) or Shiva or the feminine divine (Shakti) (e.g., Shiva's consort, Kali). Vishnu is a god which incarnates in many forms ("Avatars"), both human and non-human. Shiva is "head" of a whole family of lesser deities including various wives and sons. A Hindu will generally choose one form of one god on which to focus his or her devotions.

    The form of Hinduism known as "Vedanta" focuses more upon the "Brahman/Atman" non-personal Ultimate Reality, thus being more philosophical rather than devotional.

    Although for Buddhism, there is no "God" in the Western sense of the word, devotional forms of Buddhism have developed under influence of the cultures it has moved into. Thus in popular, lay (as opposed to monastic) practice, most Buddhists will ritually venerate the historical Buddha or some "bodhisattva" (literally: "wise being" - heavenly buddhas) The focus of Jain devotion is upon reverence for the great gurus (teachers) of their ancient past known as "Tirthankaras" (literally, "fordmakers" who forge the way for the salvation of others). These Tirthankaras are looked upon as an ideal to aspire to in one's own life. The Far East:     In China there is an ancient belief in opposing but complementary energies (symbolized by the familiar Yin-Yang image:[) in constant flux with each other which, in turn, influence all of nature, including human life. Understanding and harmonizing with these energies is the underlying focus of Chinese spirituality. "Chi", the life force, is often translated as "ultimate" suggesting that "Chi" is the ultimate energy. Such energies are impersonal rather than personal gods.
        The Chinese and Chinese influenced cultures of the far east also believe that the life of individuals continues after death and that dead ancestors continue to play an important role in the lives of the living. Related to this is a general belief in all sorts of spirit beings, both good and evil (e.g., "hungry ghosts"). To appease such spirits is the focus of the folk religion of the far east which is generally combined with philosophical systems of thought such as Taoism, Confucianism or Buddhism.
    A categorized comparison: Personal Deity                   Impersonal Ultimate Reality

    Jewish                                 Hindu
    Christian                              Buddhist
    Muslim                                Taoist
    Jain                                     Confucian
    Hindu                                  Shinto
    Zoroastrian
    Sikh
    Shinto
    Baha'i

    Supernatural                       Natural

    Jewish                                 Taoist
    Christian                              Shinto
    Muslim
    Hindu
    Zoroastrian
    Sikh
    Baha'i
    Jain

    Transcendent                       Immanent

    Jewish                                    Hindu
    Christian                                 Taoist
    Muslim                                   Confucian
    Hindu                                     Shinto
    Buddhist                                 Jain
    Zoroastrian
    Sikh
    Taoist
    Baha'i

    Monotheistic                           Polytheistic                       Non-Theistic

    Jewish                                     Hindu                                 Hindu
    Christian                                  Shinto                                 Buddhist
    Muslim                                                                              Jain
    Zoroastrian                                                                        Taoist
    Sikh                                                                                  Confucian
    Baha'i

    Religion 100 lecture notes
    Home