A COMPARATIVE LOOK AT THE WORLD'S RELIGIONS
by Laura Ellen Shulman
What do we believe about the nature of Ultimate
Reality?
(the many names of God - "a rose by any other name...")
Western Traditions:
The God of the Western, monotheistic religions is
understood to be the omnipotent, omniscient, eternal and transcendent creator
but also in relationship with humans demanding justice, obedience to God’s
will and selfless love toward others.
-
Judaism - "God" ("the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob") - initially
a family deity, then the god of a particular people (all descended from
one ancient family), eventually recognized as the One True God of all.
-
Christianity - "God" ("the Father, Son and Holy Spirit") - the God
of the Jews as revealed through Jesus the Christ (himself, a Jew).
-
Islam - "Allah" (the Arabic word for "God") is the same God which
the Jews and Christians worship.
-
Baha'i - "God" - the same God as Jews, Christians and Muslims.
-
Zoroastrianism - Often misunderstood as a dualistic faith, the Zoroastrian
God, known as "Ahura Mazda" ("Wise Lord" in Persian), is much like that
of the other Middle Eastern faiths (Jewish, Christian, Muslim, Baha'i).
Evil is basically an absence of the goodness of the lord and thus has no
absolute existence in and of itself. Evil has come to be identified as
an evil spirit called "Angra Mainyu" or Ariman, but this was not part of
the original teaching of the faith.
Indian traditions:
The eastern religions vary in focus, understanding
Ultimate Reality to be either one or many, personal gods and goddesses
or a non-personal energy or force creating, maintaining and transforming
the cosmos in an ongoing, eternal and repeating process. Often these views
will be found side by side in a single tradition differing between popular
and philosophical understanding of the same tradition.
-
Hinduism - "Brahman/Atman" "Brahman" being the non-personal and
transcendent Ultimate Reality; "Atman" being that Reality as it manifests
itself in (or as) the soul of a human being (thus the immanent form of
divinity).
There are also many, many personal deities understood as various forms
of the one Ultimate Reality. Three primary gods:
Brahma, the creator
Vishnu, the preserver
Shiva, the destroyer (transformer)
In practice, Hindus primarily worship some form of Vishnu (e.g. Krishna)
or Shiva or the feminine divine (Shakti) (e.g., Shiva's consort, Kali).
Vishnu is a god which incarnates in many forms ("Avatars"), both human
and non-human. Shiva is "head" of a whole family of lesser deities including
various wives and sons. A Hindu will generally choose one form of one god
on which to focus his or her devotions.
The form of Hinduism known as "Vedanta" focuses more upon the "Brahman/Atman"
non-personal Ultimate Reality, thus being more philosophical rather than
devotional.
-
Buddhism - "Nirvana" is more of an ultimate state of being in which
one's individual identity is totally merged in union with all (thus "Nirvana"
is often understood as non-being and literally means "blown-out" as a candle
flame is extinguished). "Nirvana" is the ultimate goal of the Buddhist.
It is a state of inner bliss, of no desire and thus of no suffering achieved
through years of meditation rather than through devotion and ritual.
Although for Buddhism, there is no "God" in the Western sense of the
word, devotional forms of Buddhism have developed under influence of the
cultures it has moved into. Thus in popular, lay (as opposed to monastic)
practice, most Buddhists will ritually venerate the historical Buddha or
some "bodhisattva" (literally: "wise being" - heavenly buddhas)
-
Jainism - Jains believe in a duality of spirit and matter. Every
soul is a potential god. There is no external, "creator" god. Every soul
is eternally separate and unique from and yet of the same quality and substance
as every other soul. The ultimate goal of the Jain is much like that of
the Buddhist - to achieve an eternal state of bliss (a "Nirvana") by freeing
the soul from this realm of matter. Having achieved this state one becomes
a Jaina - an enlightened being, a god; but this is a god that does not
relate to souls that remain embodied. Thus there is no devotion to or supplication
of such gods.
The focus of Jain devotion is upon reverence for the great gurus (teachers)
of their ancient past known as "Tirthankaras" (literally, "fordmakers"
who forge the way for the salvation of others). These Tirthankaras are
looked upon as an ideal to aspire to in one's own life.
-
Sikhism - believes in one "God" who is very much like that of the
Judeo/Christian/Muslim concept of God: personal, eternal, invisible, ineffable
but revealing Himself through all creation and especially in the human
heart. Sikhs refer to God as "Waheguru" ("Wonderful Guru") or "Sat Nam"
("True Name").
The Far East:
In China there is an ancient belief in opposing
but complementary energies (symbolized by the familiar Yin-Yang image:[)
in constant flux with each other which, in turn, influence all of nature,
including human life. Understanding and harmonizing with these energies
is the underlying focus of Chinese spirituality. "Chi", the life force,
is often translated as "ultimate" suggesting that "Chi" is the ultimate
energy. Such energies are impersonal rather than personal gods.
The Chinese and
Chinese influenced cultures of the far east also believe that the life
of individuals continues after death and that dead ancestors continue to
play an important role in the lives of the living. Related to this is a
general belief in all sorts of spirit beings, both good and evil (e.g.,
"hungry ghosts"). To appease such spirits is the focus of the folk religion
of the far east which is generally combined with philosophical systems
of thought such as Taoism, Confucianism or Buddhism.
-
Taoism - the "Tao" (literally, "Way"
or "path") is not a personal god but is the source of all that is. In it
lies the secret of harmony in all things in life. To follow the "Tao" is
to know an inner harmony which enables the Taoist to live a well balanced
life of ease, going with the flow of nature and the "way" of the world.
-
Confucianism - more a way of life,
a code of moral and social behavior than a religion to worship a god, many
Confucianists also follow some other religion (e.g., Buddhism or Taoism)
by which they may balance life in this world with a devotion to some ultimate
vision which lies beyond this world. Confucianists might also venerate
Confucius himself. There is also the concept of "Tien" - Heaven. The Emperor
links heaven and earth. Tien is manifest in the Emperor who thus rules
with "the mandate of heaven."
-
Shinto - literally, "the way (tao)
of the gods (shen)", this indigenous Japanese tradition is a nature religion,
recognizing the sacredness of all aspects of nature. As such, Shinto venerates
thousands of nature deities known collectively as "Kami". The foremost
of these is the Sun goddess, "Amaterasu". As with Confucianism, most Shinto
will also be Buddhists, the two religions not being in conflict, but rather,
balancing each other, serving different purposes.
A categorized comparison:
Personal Deity
Impersonal Ultimate Reality
Jewish
Hindu
Christian
Buddhist
Muslim
Taoist
Jain
Confucian
Hindu
Shinto
Zoroastrian
Sikh
Shinto
Baha'i
Supernatural
Natural
Jewish
Taoist
Christian
Shinto
Muslim
Hindu
Zoroastrian
Sikh
Baha'i
Jain
Transcendent
Immanent
Jewish
Hindu
Christian
Taoist
Muslim
Confucian
Hindu
Shinto
Buddhist
Jain
Zoroastrian
Sikh
Taoist
Baha'i
Monotheistic
Polytheistic
Non-Theistic
Jewish
Hindu
Hindu
Christian
Shinto
Buddhist
Muslim
Jain
Zoroastrian
Taoist
Sikh
Confucian
Baha'i
Religion
100 lecture notes
Home